Back to explore
Thumbnail for Try to Rule Fairly and You'll Be Overthrown
HN score 17.0 · explainer

Ideas, society & history

Try to Rule Fairly and You'll Be Overthrown

CGP Grey · Discussed on HN from 2016 to 2025

Editorial context · source-attributed

What the Hacker News discussion says — and what it does not

Discussion focus

Across the sampled HN recommendations, people specifically point to Video summary of The Dictator's Handbook on ruler incentives and Short intro to selectorate theory and dictator stability.

A recorded perspective

The recorded HN source is “here's a great video, Rules for Rulers, which is basically a video TL;DR of "The Dictator's Handbook” — a useful perspective from VladimirGolovin in 2016-12, rather than a claim that every Hacker News reader agrees.

Evidence boundary

Alongside recommendations, the export retains a reference mention from gooseus (2018-03): “> People with power and wealth could still be toppled when you exposed them to the truth. How in the fuck does that even come close to happening today? I have doubts that this happened regularly in the past, usually wealthy/powerful were allowed to be toppled by their enemies. I don't know the details of how Weinstein got toppled after so many years of being protected, but my gut says that the people who were protecting him no longer felt like it was worth it to continue. In revolutions, it's not the people that overthrow the dictator, it's the court/army which allow the people to overthrow the dictator, in order for them to install a new dictator[0]. > How do you overcome marketing that is engineered to exploit the psychological vulnerabilities you are not even aware of? Become more aware of your vulnerabilities so as to be aware of when you're being exploited. I recommend mindfulness and then making note of when you're being triggered in either a positive or negative way. If you know the enemy and yourself, you need not fear the result of a thousand battles[1]. > How do we patch our society and governing systems from being pwned? As these systems become more complex it requires more energy and complexity to maintain the systems, this additional complexity creates a larger attack surface and more internal fragility. Solving these problems requires more energy and complexity, exacerbating the problem and delivering diminishing returns on additional complexity. Systems should ” This is context, not proof; use the linked discussion to inspect the original thread.

Who should start here

Curious viewers exploring political power and selectorate theory. Its upstream classification is politics & history (other), while this Explorer page groups it with related material in ideas, society & history.

HN comments behind this record

6 sampled comments · 2016–2025
strong recVladimirGolovin · 2016-12

Video summary of The Dictator's Handbook on ruler incentives

“here's a great video, Rules for Rulers, which is basically a video TL;DR of "The Dictator's Handbook”
Open comment #13104381
recnickik · 2017-06

Short intro to selectorate theory and dictator stability

“Or this nice little video”
Open comment #14470090
strong recabandonliberty · 2018-07

Outline of how rulers and resource wealth interact

“CGPGrey's rules for rulers is a very good outline of this and other related topics”
Open comment #17622993
referencegooseus · 2018-03

> People with power and wealth could still be toppled when you exposed them to the truth. How in the fuck does that even come close to happening today? I have doubts that this happened regularly in the past, usually wealthy/powerful were allowed to be toppled by their enemies. I don't know the details of how Weinstein got toppled after so many years of being protected, but my gut says that the people who were protecting him no longer felt like it was worth it to continue. In revolutions, it's not the people that overthrow the dictator, it's the court/army which allow the people to overthrow the dictator, in order for them to install a new dictator[0]. > How do you overcome marketing that is engineered to exploit the psychological vulnerabilities you are not even aware of? Become more aware of your vulnerabilities so as to be aware of when you're being exploited. I recommend mindfulness and then making note of when you're being triggered in either a positive or negative way. If you know the enemy and yourself, you need not fear the result of a thousand battles[1]. > How do we patch our society and governing systems from being pwned? As these systems become more complex it requires more energy and complexity to maintain the systems, this additional complexity creates a larger attack surface and more internal fragility. Solving these problems requires more energy and complexity, exacerbating the problem and delivering diminishing returns on additional complexity. Systems should

Open comment #16638784

Topics and ideas

  • 01rules for rulers
  • 02dictators handbook
  • 03selectorate theory

CGP Grey's animated adaptation of The Dictator's Handbook, explaining how rulers stay in power by keeping a small group of key supporters happy rather than ruling fairly. It lays out selectorate theory and how resources shape regimes.

Original HackerTube classification: Politics & history (other).

Source context

Documented HN source

Video summary of The Dictator's Handbook on ruler incentives

“here's a great video, Rules for Rulers, which is basically a video TL;DR of "The Dictator's Handbook”
Read the original HN comment

VladimirGolovin · 2016-12 · 15 recommenders across 15 months

Keep exploring

Thumbnail for How to Speak
Ideas, society & historylecture
How to Speak

MIT OpenCourseWare

Documented HN sourceHN 21.0
Quick Take

HN treats it as the canonical, near-universally recommended lecture on giving talks and presentations.

Thumbnail for In Search Of A Flat Earth
Ideas, society & historydocumentary
Documented HN sourceHN 19.0
Quick Take

HN treats it as the definitive, compassionate documentary on why people fall into conspiracy theories.

Thumbnail for 1. Introduction to Human Behavioral Biology
Ideas, society & historylecture
Documented HN sourceHN 19.0
Quick Take

One of the most consistently recommended lecture series on HN, praised as fascinating, funny and eye-opening about human behavior across many scales.